Fractions are Hard!

3.2 Fractions with negative numerators and denominators

Mathematically “\(-2\)” represents the opposite of “\(2\)”, in the sense that adding \(2\) and \(-2\) together gives zero.

(See Piles and Holes for my general approach to this.)


The usual rules of arithmetic also allow us to think of \(-2\) as \(-1\times 2\) if we prefer.


Suppose now we can extend our work with fractions to include negative numbers as numerators and denominators. (Sharing anti-pie among anti-boys?)


Here’s a question:


Are \(\dfrac{-3}{5}\) and \(\dfrac{3}{-5}\) and \(-\dfrac{3}{5}\) the same fraction or are they all different as numbers?


It is hard to answer this question with our sharing model or in any of our models. (Is \(\dfrac{-3}{5}\), the result of sharing three anti-pies to five boys, the same as the result of \(\dfrac{3}{-5}\), sharing three pies to five anti boys? And are these answers both three-fifths of an anti-pie?)


But if we believe that the Key Fraction Property should hold for all types of numbers, including negative ones, then we have


\(\dfrac{-3}{5}=\dfrac{-3\times \left(-1\right)}{5\times\left(-1\right)}=\dfrac{3}{-5}\).


And we also have by our Basic Multiplication Belief that


\(-\dfrac{3}{5}=\left(-1\right) \times \dfrac{3}{5}=\dfrac{\left(-1\right)\times 3}{5}=\dfrac{-3}{5}\).


This shows all three quantities should be deemed the same number.


People call writing \(\dfrac{-a}{b}\) as \(-\dfrac{a}{b}\), and writing \(\dfrac{a}{-b}\) as \(-\dfrac{a}{b}\), as “pulling out a negative sign.”



a)       What is \(\dfrac{-a}{-b}\)?

b)      What is \(\dfrac{-8}{9}\times \dfrac{2}{-5}\)?


Please join the conversation on Facebook and Twitter and kindly share this page using the buttons below.
Share on Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter




Take your understanding to the next level with easy to understand books by James Tanton.



Guides & Solutions

Dive deeper into key topics through detailed, easy to follow guides and solution sets.


light bulb


Consider supporting G'Day Math! with a donation, of any amount.

Your support is so much appreciated and enables the continued creation of great course content. Thanks!


Ready to Help?

Donations can be made via PayPal and major credit cards. A PayPal account is not required. Many thanks!